Getting Traffic in the AI Search Era

Marketers, in New Zealand and elsewhere, are facing an unprecedented challenge. The statistics are sobering: Google's click-through ratio has plummeted from 1 click for every 2 search results a decade ago to just 1 click for every 18 search results today. Meanwhile, 58.5% of searches now end without any clicks to websites, and AI-powered features like Google AI Overviews appear in 13.14% of all queries—a 72% increase since January 2025.

But here's the crucial insight: while 95% of New Zealand SMBs using AI report enhanced earnings, and early AI search adopters are seeing conversion rates 23% higher than traditional organic search, most businesses haven't adapted their strategies. The companies that act now will capture disproportionate value as AI search evolves from representing less than 1% of current traffic to potentially 50% by 2028.

Here's how forward-thinking New Zealand marketers can not only survive but thrive in the AI era by implementing proven strategies that work alongside traditional SEO fundamentals.

Understanding the magnitude of change in search behaviour

The transformation in search behaviour extends far beyond simple statistics. AI-powered search features are reshaping how New Zealanders discover information, make purchasing decisions, and interact with brands. Google AI Overviews now appear for 88.1% of informational queries, while ChatGPT has reached 800+ million weekly active users globally, processing over 1 billion web searches weekly.

For New Zealand businesses, this shift creates both immediate challenges and significant opportunities. Research shows that 40% of Australian and New Zealand SMEs are actively adopting AI technologies, with the region leading global adoption rates. Yet most businesses haven't adjusted their digital marketing strategies to account for these fundamental changes in user behaviour.

The impact varies dramatically by industry. Entertainment queries triggering AI Overviews increased 528% during March 2025, restaurants saw 387% growth, and travel queries rose 381%. For New Zealand's tourism and hospitality sectors, this represents both a challenge in traditional traffic acquisition and an opportunity to dominate AI-powered search results.

Zero-click searches now represent the majority of search activity, with 59.7% of European searches ending without clicks—higher than the US rate of 58.5%. This means traditional SEO metrics focused purely on click-through rates are becoming less meaningful, while brand visibility and authority within AI-generated responses become critical success factors.

How AI search engines are changing traffic patterns

The emergence of AI search platforms has created a multi-engine ecosystem that New Zealand marketers must navigate strategically. While Google still commands 5.5 billion daily visits compared to 233.1 million for AI chatbots, the growth trajectory is unmistakable—AI chatbot traffic has grown 80.92% year-over-year.

Perplexity has reached 780 million queries monthly with 20% month-over-month growth, while its valuation jumped from $9 billion to $14 billion in 2025. ChatGPT search features now include shopping integration, memory capabilities, and advanced voice modes that directly compete with traditional search experiences. Microsoft Bing has grown its desktop market share from 10.51% to 12.21%, largely driven by AI-powered features.

These platforms operate differently from traditional search engines. AI search engines prioritise authoritative, structured content that directly answers user questions. They favour sources with strong E-A-T signals (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness) and are more likely to cite content that includes first-party research, expert insights, and comprehensive coverage of topics.

For New Zealand businesses, this means success requires optimisation across multiple platforms simultaneously. Companies like Hedges & Company have achieved 200% increases in AI referral traffic by implementing comprehensive AI search optimisation, while The Search Initiative helped a client achieve 2,300% growth in monthly AI referral traffic alongside 90 keywords appearing in AI overviews.

The conversion quality from AI search traffic is particularly noteworthy. Early data shows AI search visitors convert 23% higher than traditional organic search visitors, suggesting that while volume may be lower, the quality and intent of AI search traffic is superior.

What strategies are working for forward-thinking businesses

Successful businesses are implementing multi-faceted approaches that balance traditional SEO fundamentals with AI-specific optimisation strategies. The most effective strategies focus on authority building, structured content creation, and comprehensive schema markup implementation.

Globally, Rocky Brands achieved a 30% increase in search revenue and 74% year-over-year revenue growth by strategically using AI tools to align content with user search queries. Similarly, ZOE (Digital Health Platform) experienced 754% organic growth in six months by optimising for image search, featured snippets, and People Also Ask results—all features that AI tools frequently reference.

Local businesses are finding particular success with hyperlocal AI optimisation. A multi-location chain in Northern Ireland used AI-powered localisation to make each store appear as a neighbourhood business rather than a chain outlet, dramatically improving community connection and local search performance.

The key differentiator for successful businesses is systematic implementation rather than piecemeal adoption. Companies that approach AI search optimisation comprehensively—covering technical implementation, content strategy, and brand building simultaneously—consistently outperform those attempting isolated tactics.

Voice search optimisation has become particularly crucial, with 27% of New Zealanders now using voice search on mobile devices. Businesses optimising for conversational queries and natural language patterns are capturing an increasing share of this growing search segment.

Building authority and expertise for AI visibility

AI search engines heavily prioritise content from authoritative sources with clear expertise indicators. For New Zealand marketers, this means E-E-A-T optimisation has become essential rather than optional. The most successful implementations focus on demonstrable expertise through comprehensive content, first-hand experience indicators, and third-party validation.

Author authority plays a crucial role in AI citation decisions. Content with visible bylines, author credentials, and LinkedIn profiles significantly outperforms anonymous content. This is particularly important for New Zealand professional services firms, where individual expertise can differentiate businesses in competitive markets.

Digital PR has emerged as a critical component of AI search success. AI language models are trained on authoritative publications, making media mentions in trusted New Zealand sources like NZ Herald, Stuff, and Radio NZ valuable for long-term AI visibility. Companies creating original research and surveys generate natural backlinks and citations that enhance their authority signals.

Cross-platform consistency amplifies authority signals. Businesses maintaining unified messaging across websites, social media, and third-party platforms while building Wikipedia presence (for established brands) create strong entity recognition in AI knowledge graphs.

The investment in authority building pays compound returns. Ramp (Fintech) became the 5th most visible fintech brand globally within weeks by creating content specifically tailored for AI search engines, demonstrating how strategic authority building can accelerate market positioning.

Optimising content structure for AI search engines

AI search engines favour content structured for easy parsing and understanding. The most effective content follows an "answer-first" approach, providing direct responses within the first 1-2 lines before expanding with supporting detail. This mirrors how AI systems extract and present information to users.

Successful content structures include clear headers, bullet points, numbered lists, and short paragraphs that AI systems can easily segment and reference. FAQ sections have become particularly valuable, with FAQ schema markup helping content appear in People Also Ask features and AI-generated responses.

Conversational query optimisation targets the natural language patterns people use with AI assistants. This includes optimising for question-based keywords (how, what, why, when, where) and longer, more specific queries that reflect how users interact with ChatGPT and voice assistants.

Companies like Brainly achieved 522% year-over-year growth by optimising user-generated Q&A content for AI citation, creating 2+ million question landing pages that significantly increased their likelihood of being referenced by AI systems.

Topic cluster development has become essential for comprehensive coverage. Rather than targeting individual keywords, successful businesses create interconnected content that demonstrates topic authority across entire subject areas—an approach that AI systems favour when determining authoritative sources.

Schema markup and structured data implementation

Schema markup has evolved from an SEO best practice to an AI optimisation necessity. Structured data helps AI systems interpret content with 300% higher accuracy compared to unstructured data, making comprehensive schema implementation critical for AI visibility.

Essential schema types for New Zealand businesses include LocalBusiness schema for location-based searches, Product schema for e-commerce visibility, FAQ schema for voice search optimisation, and Article schema for content pieces. Each schema type serves specific AI search functions while improving traditional search performance.

The implementation approach matters significantly. JSON-LD format is preferred for its clean separation from content, while validation through Google's Rich Results Test ensures proper implementation. Businesses implementing comprehensive schema markup report improved visibility across both traditional and AI search results.

Connected schema strategies build relationships between entities on websites, helping AI systems understand business structures and service relationships. This is particularly valuable for New Zealand businesses with multiple locations or complex service offerings.

Advanced implementations include SameAs schema linking to authoritative external sources (Wikipedia, Wikidata, social profiles) and Speakable markup that helps voice assistants identify content sections for audio responses—critical as voice search represents 27% of mobile queries in New Zealand.

Local SEO adaptations for New Zealand markets

Local SEO has become increasingly important as AI search engines prioritise location-relevant results. Google Business Profile optimisation remains fundamental, with AI-powered local search features relying heavily on complete, accurate GBP information. This includes comprehensive business descriptions, regular posting schedules, and prompt review responses (within 24 hours).

New Zealand-specific directory listings have gained importance for AI visibility. Essential platforms include Yellow Pages NZ (with 70,000+ NZ businesses listed), Neighbourly for community-focused searches, and Hotfrog for international visibility. Consistent NAP (Name, Address, Phone) information across these platforms strengthens entity recognition for AI systems.

Cultural considerations play a crucial role in New Zealand AI optimisation. Māori language integration in content and search strategies can differentiate businesses while serving New Zealand's unique cultural context. Regional terminology variations across North and South Islands require localised keyword strategies.

Voice search has particular relevance for local businesses, with 78% of local mobile searches resulting in offline purchases within 24 hours. Optimising for conversational local queries ("Where can I find the best coffee in Ponsonby Auckland?") captures increasing voice search volume.

Local content strategies should include location-specific landing pages, local landmark references, and community involvement content. Businesses covering local events and using regional terminology while maintaining professional standards achieve better AI search visibility for location-based queries.

Advanced strategies for voice search and conversational AI

Voice search represents a rapidly growing segment requiring specific optimisation approaches. With 20.5% of people worldwide actively using voice search and 8.4 billion voice assistants in use globally, New Zealand businesses must optimise for conversational query patterns.

Successful voice search optimisation targets long-tail, question-based queries that mirror natural speech patterns. This includes optimising for direct questions customers ask about products and services, rather than shorter keyword phrases used in typed searches.

Featured snippet optimisation has become essential for voice search success, as voice assistants typically read featured snippet content as responses. Content structured in definition, list, and table formats performs best for voice search applications. This requires creating concise, direct answers that provide immediate value.

Technical implementation includes Speakable structured data that marks text sections for voice assistant reading, accessibility optimisation with descriptive alt text, and Core Web Vitals improvements that help AI systems parse content more effectively.

Local voice search requires specific attention to "near me" queries and conversational location-based searches. Businesses optimising for natural language patterns ("Find a dentist open late in Auckland") capture voice search traffic that often converts at higher rates than traditional searches.

E-commerce and product optimisation in the AI era

E-commerce businesses face unique challenges and opportunities in AI search. Product schema implementation has become essential for visibility in Google Shopping and AI-powered product recommendations. This includes detailed product information, pricing, availability, and review data that AI systems use for product comparisons.

ChatGPT's shopping integration and Perplexity's one-click checkout features create new sales channels for e-commerce businesses. Companies optimising product descriptions for AI understanding while maintaining comprehensive technical specifications achieve better visibility across these emerging platforms.

Visual search optimisation has gained importance, with AI systems increasingly using image recognition for product discovery. This requires optimised product images with descriptive file names, comprehensive alt text, and structured data that helps AI systems understand product attributes and categories.

Amazon sellers using AI for listing optimisation report significant performance improvements, with 34% using AI for writing and optimising product listings. For New Zealand e-commerce businesses, this represents both a competitive threat and an opportunity to leverage AI tools for enhanced product visibility.

Customer review optimisation has become crucial for AI recommendations. AI systems heavily weight customer feedback when making product suggestions, making review management and response strategies essential components of e-commerce AI optimisation.

Measuring success in the AI search landscape

Traditional SEO metrics require supplementation with AI-specific performance indicators. While AI search currently drives less than 1% of traffic for most websites, early adopters report conversion rates 23% higher than traditional organic search, making quality metrics more important than pure volume measurements.

Key performance indicators include AI referral traffic percentages, brand mention frequency in AI responses, share of voice across generative search engines, and keyword rankings in AI overviews (which now appear in 57% of SERPs as of June 2025).

Tracking tools have evolved to accommodate AI search measurement. Google Analytics 4 custom channel groups help identify AI search traffic, while specialised tools like Peec.ai track brand mentions across AI platforms. Enterprise solutions like Profound monitor AI visibility across multiple search engines.

BrightEdge research shows that 750+ organisations are using AI monitoring tools, with 68% actively changing strategies based on AI search performance data. For New Zealand businesses, early adoption of AI measurement tools provides competitive advantages in strategy optimisation.

The growth trajectory suggests measurement will become increasingly important. With AI referral traffic growing 165 times faster than organic search and conversion rates consistently higher, businesses tracking and optimising for AI search metrics are positioning themselves for significant advantages as adoption accelerates.

Frequently asked questions (FAQ) about AI search optimisation

Q. How quickly should New Zealand businesses expect to see results from AI search optimisation?

AI search optimisation typically shows initial results within 2-3 months for basic implementations like schema markup and content restructuring. However, substantial traffic growth often requires 6-12 months of consistent optimisation across multiple AI platforms. Companies like The Search Initiative achieved 2,300% growth over several months through systematic implementation, while others see gradual improvements that compound over time.

Q. What budget should small New Zealand businesses allocate for AI search tools and optimisation?

Small businesses should budget $200-400 monthly for essential AI SEO tools (Semrush Pro at $129/month, local SEO tools around $50/month, and AI content assistance at $30/month). Mid-market businesses typically invest $600-800 monthly for comprehensive platforms, while enterprises may spend $1,800+ monthly for advanced AI optimisation tool suites and custom development.

Q. Is traditional SEO still important if AI search is growing rapidly?

Traditional SEO remains crucial because it provides the foundation for AI search success. Websites ranking #1 on Google appear in AI search answers 25% of the time, and traditional search still drives 99%+ of traffic for most businesses. The most successful approach combines strong traditional SEO fundamentals with AI-specific optimisation strategies.

Q. How can local New Zealand businesses compete with larger companies in AI search results?

Local businesses can leverage their community connections, specific regional expertise, and localised content to achieve AI search visibility. Implementing comprehensive local schema markup, creating location-specific content, and building relationships with local media provides advantages that larger companies often struggle to replicate at scale.

Q. What are the biggest mistakes New Zealand businesses make with AI search optimisation?

Common mistakes include focusing solely on AI tools without addressing fundamental SEO issues, creating AI-generated content without human oversight and expertise signals, implementing schema markup incorrectly, and neglecting to track AI search performance metrics. Successful businesses take systematic, comprehensive approaches rather than attempting isolated tactics.

Q. Should businesses optimise for specific AI platforms like ChatGPT or Perplexity individually?

The most effective approach optimises for AI search principles that work across platforms rather than targeting individual AI engines. This includes creating authoritative, well-structured content with comprehensive schema markup, building brand authority through digital PR, and implementing E-E-A-T signals that all AI systems value.

The competitive advantage of early AI search adoption

New Zealand businesses implementing AI search optimisation now are positioning themselves for significant competitive advantages. With AI search adoption accelerating rapidly but most businesses not yet adapting strategies, early movers can establish market dominance before competitors recognize the shift.

The conversion quality advantage of AI search traffic suggests that even small increases in AI visibility can significantly impact revenue. Companies reporting 23% higher conversion rates from AI search visitors are seeing substantial ROI from optimisation investments, even with current low traffic volumes.

Market timing favours early adoption. As AI search platforms mature and user adoption increases, competition for visibility will intensify. Businesses building authority signals, implementing technical optimisation, and creating AI-friendly content now will have substantial advantages when AI search represents larger traffic percentages.

The New Zealand market's high AI adoption rates (40% of SMEs actively using AI) create both competitive pressure and opportunity. Forward-thinking businesses can leverage this early adoption to build market leadership positions that will be difficult for competitors to overcome as AI search becomes mainstream.

Taking action: your AI search optimisation roadmap

Success in the AI era requires systematic implementation across multiple fronts. Begin with foundational elements that provide immediate benefits while building toward more sophisticated strategies that position your business for long-term success.

Phase 1 (Months 1-2): Foundation Building Start with technical audits to assess current site structure and identify optimisation opportunities. Implement essential schema markup including LocalBusiness, FAQ, and Article schemas. Conduct comprehensive content audits to identify gaps and optimisation priorities. Set up tracking tools to measure AI search performance from the beginning.

Phase 2 (Months 2-4): Content Optimisation Restructure existing content to follow answer-first approaches that AI systems prefer. Develop comprehensive FAQ sections addressing customer questions. Create location-specific content for local search optimisation. Begin digital PR efforts to build authority signals and media mentions.

Phase 3 (Months 4-6): Advanced Implementation Target specific AI Overview appearances for high-value keywords. Implement complex schema relationships that demonstrate topic authority. Analyse performance data to refine strategies based on actual results. Conduct competitive analysis to identify AI search opportunities.

Phase 4 (Months 6+): Scale and Innovation Expand successful content strategies across broader topic areas. Integrate advanced AI SEO tools for workflow automation. Develop comprehensive reporting systems for ongoing optimisation. Adapt strategies based on emerging AI search trends and platform updates.

Conclusion: thriving in the new search paradigm

The AI era represents the most significant shift in digital marketing since the emergence of search engines themselves. New Zealand businesses that recognise this transformation and adapt their strategies accordingly will not only survive the traffic decline but emerge stronger with higher-quality visitors, better conversion rates, and sustainable competitive advantages.

The evidence is compelling: while traditional click-through rates decline, AI search adoption accelerates, and user behaviour fundamentally shifts toward zero-click searches, the businesses implementing comprehensive AI optimisation strategies are achieving remarkable results. From 200% traffic increases to 23% higher conversion rates, the early adopters are proving that success in the AI era isn't just possible—it's potentially more rewarding than traditional search success.

For New Zealand marketers, the opportunity window is narrowing. With 95% of local SMBs using AI reporting enhanced earnings and AI search platforms adding millions of users monthly, the competitive landscape will intensify rapidly. The strategies outlined in this guide provide a roadmap for not just adapting to change, but leveraging it for unprecedented growth.

The future belongs to businesses that understand AI search isn't replacing traditional SEO—it's creating a new layer of optimisation that rewards authority, expertise, and user-focused content creation. By implementing these strategies systematically and measuring results carefully, New Zealand businesses can transform the challenge of declining click-through rates into the opportunity of a lifetime.

Start with the fundamentals, build systematically, and prepare for a future where AI search success determines market leadership. The businesses that act now will define their industries in the AI era.

--

For a more detailed guide to the use of AI for marketing, check out our online training course:

USING AI FOR MARKETING

It’s now more important than ever for businesses to master the essential elements of AI for marketing.

Dive into the digital future with our AI for Marketers course! This exclusive training is your golden ticket to mastering AI in the marketing realm, specially designed for New Zealand’s vibrant marketing community.

Unlock the power to revolutionize your strategies, elevate content creation, and decode consumer insights like never before. Whether you’re aiming to amplify engagement, boost conversions, or innovate with unparalleled personalization, this course is your pathway to becoming an AI-savvy marketer.

Check out the details of our AI for Marketers online training course here.

We also have an AI course specifically for advertising professionals:

AI FOR ADVERTISING PROFESSIONALS

This ten-part course offers informative hands-on training designed to demystify AI and make it accessible to NZ marketers and advertising professionals. It's been developed by a New Zealand advertising professional with decades of experience in both traditional and digital marketing.

Check out the details of our AI for Advertising Professionals online training course here.

Or you might like to check out our course on the latest developments in Digital Marketing (which has AI embedded throughout):

Check out the details of our NZ Digital Marketing Essentials 2025 online training course here.